Question from Christian on 2/5/2008:
I am Lutheran but my girlfriend is Catholic. I have been told by numerous people, including a priest, that Lutherans cannot receive Communion in a Catholic church because the beliefs are different. Growing up Lutheran, I was taught that we are receiving the actual body and blood of Christ when we receive communion.
The people I spoke with were under the impression that Lutherans receive a "representation" of the body and blood of Christ, which is incorrect. The spoken words at both masses, Lutheran and Catholic, are identical as well. Can I receive Commmunion at a Catholic church? If not, why?
Answer by Catholic Answers on 2/5/2008:
Christian--
Although there are extraordinary circumstances in which a Lutheran may receive Catholic Communion, under ordinary circumstances he may not. Receiving Catholic Communion indicates by his action that the communicant believes and accepts all that the Catholic Church teaches and is in full communion with the Church. In other words, that he is a Catholic. Generally speaking then, to receive Catholic Communion when one is not in full communion with the Catholic Church is to deceive with your body.
Some Lutherans may believe that their communion is the actual body and blood of Christ, but, objectively speaking, Lutheran communion is not a valid Eucharist. It is not really Christ's body and blood because the celebrant does not have the valid holy orders necessary to confect the bread and wine into Christ's body and blood. Thus, despite surface similarities between the services, a Lutheran communion service is not the same thing as a Catholic Mass.
If you would like to receive Catholic Communion, I encourage you to consider studying Catholicism to see if you could in conscience become a Catholic. Jesus Christ longs to be sacramentally one with all those who believe in him; he simply asks that we approach him on his terms and not our own. God bless.
Recommended reading:
Pillar of Fire, Pillar of Truth
How to Become a Catholic
Michelle Arnold
Catholic Answers
///Some Lutherans may believe that their communion is the actual body and blood of Christ, but, objectively speaking...///
ReplyDeleteDear brother in Christ,
The doctrine of receiving true body and true blood of Christ in Eucharist is not "a believing of some Lutherans" but a solid statement. Those who do not confess this doctrine cannot call himself 'Lutheran'. I suppose you know this fact and do not lead another 'Catholic' believers in misunderstanding. In other words, we cannot "speak objectively" on questions that demand faith otherwise you will be forced to prove The Real Presence with P. Rahdbert's arguments only. :)))
///...Lutheran communion is not a valid Eucharist. It is not really Christ's body and blood because the celebrant does not have the valid holy orders necessary to confect the bread and wine into Christ's body and blood.///
This is an example of another ambiguity, actually. I guess you are unconsciously confusing 'validity' and 'efficacy' of sacraments. Sharing your point of view we should make a decision that it is a celebrant who 'transforms' bread and wine the bread and wine into true Christ's body and blood.
What are the extrodinary circumstances for a Lutheran to be able to receive communion in a Catholic Cuhurch...a wedding? and if so,how does one get this permission? Thank you.
ReplyDeleteThe Lutheran Communion is True Communion.
ReplyDeleteThe Communion of Roman Church is Magic.One they belive that they can transfer the Body in Hoste and vinne in Blod.
This is diffrence.
Pastor.Jerremy
Are you familiar with the Lutheran/Roman Catholic Dialogues? Read the Eucharist: A Lutheran-Roman Catholic Statement at the Us Conference of Catholic Bishops Website. I think this should answer your questions and correct some of your statements.
ReplyDeletehttp://nccbuscc.org seia/luthrc_eucharist_1968.shtml
Pax tecum--Fr. Jack